AI ALIGNMENT FORUM
AF

Tool AIAI
Frontpage

6

[ Question ]

Why not tool AI?

by smithee
19th Jan 2019
1 min read
A
1
11

6

Tool AIAI
Frontpage
Why not tool AI?
16Ben Pace
1Bird Concept
New Answer
New Comment

1 Answers sorted by
top scoring

Ben Pace

Jan 19, 2019*

160

You mention having looked through the literature; in case you missed any, here's what I think of as the standard resources on this topic.

  • Gwern's analysis of why Tool AIs want to become Agent AIs. It contains references to many other works. (It also has a positive review from Eliezer.)
  • Eric Drexler's incredibly long report on Comprehensive AI Services as General Intelligence. Related: Rohin Shah's summary, and Richard Ngo's comment.
  • The Goals and Utility Functions chapter of Rohin Shah's Value Learning sequence.
  • Eliezer's very well-written post on Arbital addressing the question "Why Expected Utility?" [Added: crossposted to LessWrong here]
  • The LessWrong wiki article on Tool AI links to several posts on this topic.

All are very worth reading.

Edit: There was an old discussion between Holden Karnofsky + Jaan Tallinn on Tool AI in yahoo groups, but Yahoo Groups has been deprecated. Here's the page in the wayback machine, but the attachment is not available. I would appreciate someone here leaving a link to that old document, I recall it being quite thoughtful.

Add Comment
[-]Bird Concept4y10

Jaan/Holden convo link is broken :(

Reply
-1 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 9:04 PM
Moderation Log
More from smithee
View more
Curated and popular this week
A
1
0

An extremely basic question that, after months of engaging with AI safety literature, I'm surprised to realize I don't fully understand: why not tool AI?

AI Safety scenarios seem to conceive of AI as an autonomous agent. Is that because of the current machine learning paradigm, where we're setting the AI's goals but not specifying the steps to get there? Is this paradigm the entire reason why AI safety is an issue?

If so, is there a reason why advanced AI would need an agenty utility function sort of set up? Is it just too cumbersome to give step by step instructions for high level tasks?

Thanks!