AI ALIGNMENT FORUM
AF

Abstraction 2020
Abstraction
Frontpage

11

Causal Abstraction Intro

by johnswentworth
19th Dec 2019
1 min read
6

11

Abstraction
Frontpage
Previous:
Abstraction, Causality, and Embedded Maps: Here Be Monsters
No comments26 karma
Next:
Definitions of Causal Abstraction: Reviewing Beckers & Halpern
No comments30 karma
Log in to save where you left off
Causal Abstraction Intro
3Ramana Kumar
New Comment
1 comment, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 5:33 PM
[-]Ramana Kumar6y30

Didn't watch the video but would have read the post. Might watch the video only because previous posts have been appetising enough.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from johnswentworth
View more
Curated and popular this week
1Comments

I haven't been terribly satisfied by the first few posts in this sequence; they don't do a very good job introducing things. I think part of the problem is the format, so I decided to invest in a high-end studio and try making a video instead.

It's about 10 minutes, covers similar material to the first few posts, but IMO does a better job communicating what's going on.

Causal Abstraction Intro

Feedback on the format is appreciated (including "didn't watch the video but would have read a normal post" or vice versa). So far I think the video provides better explanation per-unit-effort, and I lean toward doing more of them. Obviously both the setup and the postprocessing were pretty low-investment on this one; I'll probably put a bit more effort into production if I'm going to do this regularly.

Mentioned in
15Formulating Reductive Agency in Causal Models
6Trace: Goals and Principles